Was Evita As Great/Terrible As Everyone Says?

I’m here in Buenos Aires, trying to understand if Evita was good or bad, if her achievements deserve praise or not. The only thing people agree about is that Evita changed Argentina forever. Click on the right of the image to go to the next slide.

In 1996, Madonna arrived in Buenos Aires to film Evita. Everyone protested! The movie would portray Evita in a bad way! Or glorify her!

Nobody was happy! President Menem was unsure about Madonna singing on the balcony of the Casa Rosada, where Evita stood in front of thousands in the plaza!

Madonna kept a journal during her time filming Evita. I’ll have a link at the end of this post.

Director Alan Parker also has an interesting (shorter) article. At a press conference in Buenos Aires, reporters were yelling at each other instead of asking Parker their questions.

I’ve been trying to understand if Evita was good or bad. I’m standing here in the kitchen of the former Eva Perón Foundation, now the Evita Museum.

This is where you come to hear all about the good things that Eva Perón did for her country.

This Foundation was created to help Argentina’s very poor. - In 1948, she gave women the right to vote.

- Evita handed out toys to poor children at Christmas time.

She wanted to make sure they had presents, too.

- She created a nursing school so poor women could have careers and pull themselves out of poverty.

- Evita gave the poor food and medicines.

After she was born, her father abandoned the family. Her mother had to sew clothing to support the five children.

In the next room, you can see the movie poster for La Prologa, starring Evita.

The movie is about a wealthy, wasteful woman who decides to dedicate herself to the poor.

The public never saw the movie. Eva Duarte had just married Juan Perón. The couple didn’t think the movie was appropriate for a president and a First Lady.

The couple became wildly popular, especially Evita, thanks to all her Foundation did to help the country’s poor.

But Evita found out she had uterine cancer.

We all know Evita singing from the balcony of the Casa Rosada, the presidential offices in Buenos Aires.

“Don’t Cry For Me, Argentina.” She never said those words, but that was the sentiment.

And she didn’t sing to her public, los descamisados (the shirtless ones). The tone of the speech sounds very different.

Evita was shouting with anger, urging people to defend Juan Perón with their lives after she’s dead.

She knew the military was threatening to overthrow her husband.

Evita died in 1952. She was just 33 years old.

In June 1955, the military bombed the Casa Rosada.

The plaza in front was filled with thousands of Perón’s supporters. Over 300 of them died.

President Perón managed to escape. But just three months later, he was overthrown and forced into exile.

The new military government closed the Eva Perón Foundation and burned everything inside.

They said the Foundation was a propaganda machine and nothing else. They withheld vaccinations from the poor because each one had Eva Perón’s name.

They also said that labor unions and other groups and individuals were forced to donate to the foundation, thanks to Perón’s legislation.

She justified wearing designer clothes in her book, My Reason For Living:

“Like all women, I also like to look beautiful for the people I love more than I do for strangers… and that’s why I wear my best outfits for the shirtless working people.”

I read a book called The Real Lives of Evita. I’ve talked to people here in Buenos Aires. I visited the museum. I saw the movie.

Sometimes the more you learn about a subject, the harder it is to understand.

This is an experimental post format that doesn’t allow comments.

But I love comments! Please leave them on INSTAGRAM and TWITTER: @moodandmystery.